Karan Johar’s directorial venture Student of the Year,
starring debutantes Sidharth Malhotra and off springs of Hindi Cinema’s film making biggies Varun Dhawan and Alia Bhatt, acts as a perfect launch pad
for their entry into the industry. It more than often seems like a big
catalogue quite literally as the actors re-introduce themselves through songs
and boxers akin John in Dostana at various junctures in the first half. Also
Sidharth’s character’s entry almost reminds us of Hritik’s college entry in
K3g.
The film is about Rohan (Varun Dhawan) a rich brat
disregarded by his father for his rock star dreams,Shanaya (Alia Bhatt) another
rich girl in a step family looking for love and Abhimanyu (Sidharth Malhotra)
an extremely ambitious ‘bata’ boy from a small town aspiring to become
absolutely successful ,thrown into a 25 year old structurally flawed completion
‘student of the year’ started by the dean (Rishi Kapoor).
The film’s storyline on the outside looks as a comment on
the structure of competition in a student’s life but at its core is about the
friendship between the two alpha males (Sidharth and Varun).This is precisely
why Alia Bhatt seems to descend down to a supporting character. The movie doesn't allow too much acting scope; still Alia seems to fit the shoe of the
drama-queen-yearning-for-love character. Varun Dhawan and Sidharth Malhotra
both show good acting skills, look good throughout with their good physique and
boast good dancing skills.
The movie adopts the tried and tested as well as very much
in vogue flashback style of unfolding the story so that the audience remains
excited till the end but sadly the story from the beginning seems very much
predictable ,even the trailer spilling the beans since the time it glossed the
media across the nation.
The dialogues of the movie by Niranjan Iyengar are very
appropriate, realistic and quirky at times lending the movie various comic
reliefs. These comic scenes hold the movie together preventing it to go down
under. The costume designing by Manish Malhotra is again apt for all characters
including the supporting ones, except for the deep low v-neck sherwanis worn by
the leads in the song Radha which looks irritating. The first half is
consistent of a lot of portfolio frames making it seem like an ad film .The
plastic appearance of the schools and colleges have been common on the
celluloid but here even a character’s comment that St. Teresa “koi normal
school nahi tha” fails to defend its hyped portrayal as after the characters
are introduced and the plot shows their lifestyle a retort by Shanaya(Alia)
that “mera abhi lecture hai” makes the audience think “really?” .
The music by Vishal and Shekhar is intelligent as it
reprises old songs at many places .The disco song, velle and ishq wala love
being hit numbers. But the songs surface in very short successions which seem
like a tactic to cover up for the short plot whose crux shown in the second half.
Therefore major action unfolds in the second half.
Compared to other big production movies like Dabangg , Om Shanti
Om and Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi which also launched debutants along with superstars
Sharukh Khan and Salman Khan, Karan Johar through this movie balances the new
entrants with an awesome supporting cast featuring the ever so brilliant actor
Rishi Kapoor , small screen’s Amitabh Bachchan –Ronit Roy, Ram Kapoor with his
strong screen presence ,the all time favourite dadi Farida Jalal ,Manjot Singh
of Oye lucky lucky oye and the grown up in surprising avatar Sana Saeed– the
little Anjali from Kuch Kuch Hota Hai .
Given the incredible half like and half dislike for the
movie trailer on YouTube, for those confused this movie although predictable
manages to hold one time watch tag. Fulfilling the standard Kjo style film making
this is a grand rocket launching the three newbie.
very nice very nice :)
ReplyDeleteGood work Anjali :-)
ReplyDeletethankyou so much choti and megha di! :D
ReplyDeleteAnjali very nice
ReplyDeletethankyou!
ReplyDelete